Life on Mars?

Comments

Yes, it would be cool but it would need a lot of carbon dioxide from somewhere.
We seem to be pretty good at creation carbon dioxide and pumping it into the air, I'm sure that's the least of our troubles if this project were to be undertaken.
[this is good]

There's a lot of carbon dioxide already on Mars, locked up in the polar caps. That's not ice up there, it's frozen CO2. If it's not enough, I think the most plausible technology would be the introduction of genetically engineered microbes to produce more CO2 out of existing materials.

The biggest hurdle to terraforming Mars is that it would take hundreds of years, and no organization that has the resources to do it has that much foresight.

Yeah, the science seems plausable to me. The bureaucracy seems like the biggest hurdle.
[this is good]

Personally I think the big elephant in the room is: wouldn't living on Mars be miserable? Humans evolved to crave the outdoors (on Earth, that is) and the effect that living on Mars will have on the human mind may be very ugly indeed.

My big issue is that this will give the most selfish among us an excuse to resume trashing the Earth. This is what breeding wildlife in captivity and reintroduction of wolves into Yellowstone has done. Now the public just says, "Oh, that's good. If all the tigers go extinct in the wild, the zoos can just make more of them".

It's that selfish, materialistic attitude that makes the world uglier rather than more beautiful.

Living on Mars definitely would be a challenge, but I think it's a more ugly thing to deny the quest for knowledge, to explore, and to expand the scope of the success of our species. If you think back to the explorers of the 13th and 14th centuries, they spent years on boats in the open ocean and certainly paid a price, but the rewards were much greater. Plus, they didn't have the support of scientists and engineers, either. I think there are those who would gladly take up the challenge.

And I must say, I completely disagree with the notion of selfishness and materialism. I don't think that's how people think at all.

The history of evolution is pretty clear. Our species will either continue to expand into new territory, or we will eventually go extinct.

Yes, the human body evolved to live here on Earth, but it evolved in a very, very small range of climates. Humans now live in many climates that our bodies were just never designed for. We are extremely adaptable, which is our gift and eventually will be our curse if we breed ourselves into universal poverty. Even if we manage to find a way to balance our growth and environment into a permanently sustainable state, eventually something will happen - asteroid collision, solar fluctuations, global pandemic - that will threaten our species if we continue to keep all our eggs in one basket. Colonizing other worlds is something that we will do, or die.

And I don't think people will trash the planet more if there happens to be another one out there somewhere that we could live on, just like I don't trash my house just because there are other houses I could move to. Some people might use it as an excuse, but they are the people who would trash the planet regardless.

[this is good]

Oh, I completely agree that discovery makes the world more beautiful. I grew up facinated by Mars, and my aunt had the coolest book - it showed, if animals could live on other planets, what they would have to look like in order to survive. It made me want to study science and astronomy. It made me love animals.

However, discovery is different than mutating our natural world. Humans evolved to depend on the Earth for survival. If we had to create artificial conditions in which to live on a planet that does not support mammals, something would go wrong. Freaky diseases, freaky cancers. Like it or not, the Earth developed a natural world that would be almost impossible to recreate without dangers we face today by GMOs and other unnatrual technologies.

I may be 100 percent wrong - and if Mars were habitable, it would certainly take a big burden off of our Earth. That would be great! But from my limited scientific training, I took away a deep belief that nature created a world that will never be replicated in the same way. :)

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

Stephen

About Me

Stephen
United States
Luck is probability taken personally.
AIM:
deadgraviti

My Groups

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives

  • Powered by Vox